Diets for IBD, Gut Feelings, Specific Carbohydrate Diet

My First Impressions of the Specific Carbohydrate Diet

A white bowl of yellow-brown broth or soup from above, next to a metal spoon, atop a plaid blue-and-white tablecloth with white flowers in the tablecloth pattern.

In the days before I switched to the Specific Carbohydrate Diet, my ulcerative colitis was rapidly spiraling out of control. Each day I had more, and nastier, bowel movements, culminating in twelve on Day 1 of the diet. I felt terrible—constantly tired, my stomach bloated and painful. And I was scared. Each time I scrambled to the bathroom, I fought feelings of fear and hopelessness.

But within a few days of starting the new diet, a miracle began to occur. My symptoms were gradually improving. Hope, tentative at first, began to blossom within me. I had fewer and fewer bowel movements, tapering off at two or three per day. The blood in my stool decreased. My pain and discomfort decreased, too—within a week, my stomach (really my colon) seemed to have settled down.

One morning, for the first time in weeks, I awoke pain free.

I couldn’t believe it. This diet might actually be working!


The diet was by far the most rigorous one I’d ever been on. Its title is misleading. “Specific Carbohydrate Diet” sounds like eating a lot of carbs, when really you’re eating a lot of meat, at least at first.

The diet is followed in phases. You begin with the easiest-to-digest foods and build to more difficult ones as your intestines heal. That means the first phase is the most limited of all.

Here are the things you can eat in the introductory phase:

  • Eggs
  • Apple cider (diluted with water)
  • Grape juice (diluted with water)
  • Grape jello
  • Chicken soup (ingredients: chicken, broth, and cooked, pureed carrots)
  • Beef patty (broiled)
  • Fish (broiled)

That’s it. Literally. You can add no ingredients other than the ones I just mentioned, except perhaps spices.

It took several days to prepare for this change. Once again, I had to establish new routines in the kitchen. I commenced the diet, and each day I began eating a pound—a pound—of plain, broiled beef patties, plus two bowls of chicken soup.

The fatigue of my colitis was still intense in those first few days. Upon starting the diet I spent a whole weekend lying on the couch watching shows on Hulu. I’d been experiencing fatigue like this since starting the Canasa suppositories, which I was still using in case they were doing something. (I liked to be scientific and only change one thing at a time, so I was changing my diet without changing my meds.)

My doctor said fatigue wasn’t one of Canasa’s symptoms, but my husband Ron pointed out that the fatigue was probably from the illness itself. The Canasa wasn’t working, and ongoing diarrhea and blood were wiping me out. So I figured part of this fatigue was probably just a carryover, not from the new diet. I’d been very sick for weeks, and it would take time to regain strength.

But there was a new symptom that I was sure was the diet. I started experiencing sensations I could only describe as…weird. I couldn’t pinpoint exactly what was wrong, but it just felt like some crucial element was missing from my body. I felt generally toxic, tired, and fuzzy-headed.

On Day 6, I awoke feeling energetic for the first time in weeks. I wrote “Energized!” that day in my food log, where I had started recording my symptoms and diet in detail. But the next day my fatigue returned. It hit like a wave, relegating me again to the couch. Very luckily, I worked at home and could rest as needed, although by now I had fallen far behind on my projects.


I was doing my cooking in big batches. Every four or five days I settled into the kitchen for several hours, filling up all our Pyrex storage containers with my plain chicken soup, plain ground beef patties, pureed carrots, and grape jello, which I then subsisted on for the next several days. This big-batch cooking method saved me the trouble and energy it would take to cook every day. At each meal, I ate out of a single bowl that I rotated several times through the microwave, filling it with first one item, then the next, then the next.

Aside from the fatigue and “weirdness,” things were going well enough that I could now begin adding new foods. I did this carefully, one at a time, in the order prescribed by the diet. I waited a day or two each time, checking for new symptoms before adding the next.

The first addition was cheese. I couldn’t wait to taste it—cheese was perhaps my favorite food, and by now I’d been off dairy for several weeks. This diet allowed dry curd cottage cheese at first, and I spooned it carefully out of its package, white as snow, moist as damp earth. I brought the spoon to my mouth and sampled it, savoring it like a kiss. It was wonderful.

The next day I ate the usual for lunch: first my two plain, broiled burgers, microwaved, eaten with a fork. Next, the last of my peeled-cooked-pureed carrots (I would make some more tomorrow). Some grape jello to top it off, but in between, one more bite of the new, heavenly cheese, its luster faded slightly now that I was used to it.

Then I added applesauce, today’s new food. As with the cheese the day before, the applesauce’s flavor exploded through my mouth. It tasted like sunrise. Like walking barefoot through an orchard. Never before had I appreciated the incredible flavor of apples! This diet was making me appreciate each new food like never before.


The following day, it was time to add the SCD’s special homemade yogurt. Elaine Gottschall, the diet’s main proponent, explains that homemade yogurt has far more good bacteria than store-bought probiotic yogurt, because at home you can ferment your yogurt for longer, perhaps 24 hours.

I had dutifully bought a yogurt maker and yogurt starter. Making yogurt had turned out to be as easy as Gottschall described: you just heat up whole milk to near boiling, let it cool a bit, mix in a packet of yogurt starter, and let it ferment in the yogurt maker. It had been satisfying to open the yogurt maker the night before and find a big batch of plain, white homemade yogurt warming inside.

I had let it cool in the fridge overnight. When I removed the plastic lid now, there it was: a smooth, jiggly white cylinder, its edges slightly pocked. My lips puckered at its sour flavor, but it tasted sweeter than the store-bought varieties. I willed its bacteria to work their magic inside me.


On Day 11, for the first time since diagnosis, I awoke looking forward to time in the kitchen. I had never really enjoyed cooking, although I wanted to. I wanted to want to cook. But today, I did want to cook. Possibly because today’s new item was cheesecake.

Cheesecake! It was to be crustless, made with the homemade yogurt as well as the dry curd cottage cheese, honey—another recent ingredient—and eggs. I couldn’t wait.

I spent four hours in the kitchen. Making the cheesecake, plus all my other food for the next several days, was daunting and tiring but also satisfying. It felt good to have a rhythm and to feel less pain, to finally be on a path that might actually lead where I wanted to go.

And the cheesecake tasted as heavenly as any I’d ever eaten.

“Want a bite?” I asked Ron.

He closed his eyes as the yellowy substance melted in his mouth. “Mmmm.”

I grinned, practically wagging my tail. “Are you jealous?”

“Yes.”

“Good.”

For once, Ron was jealous of my food.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *